Did you know that banjos and violins are not the same things? They may look similar, but they have different styles of music, sounds, purposes, and histories. And perhaps the most important question is, Banjo or Violin?
In this blog post, we will explore almost everything about Banjo vs violin so that you can decide which one is right for you.
What is Banjo?
Banjo is a stringed musical instrument made up of a plastic body, metal strings, and one or two prongs on the head, to be held between the knees while playing. There are many other genres of Banjo played in North America, South America, Africa, Europe, Asia, etc. There are many Banjo types for different musical notes. The Banjo was initially used for song accompaniment, either vocally or instrumentally. It was adopted for singing work songs and hollers with time because of its loud volume and portability. Later on, it became a staple of American fiddle music. In this style, the lead melody is usually played on a higher string while those following are tuned to a lower octave.
What is Violin?
A violin is a bowed string instrument with frets. It has four strings and is played with a bow. The Violin originated in the 16th century and became popular in the 18th century. Today it is used in classical music, jazz, country, and bluegrass and can also be used as an acoustic instrument in rock and folk music. The Violin is made of wood and has a hollow body. It is held between the shoulder and chin, and the bow is drawn across the strings to create sound.
Banjo vs Violin: Differences
Different Looks and Body Types
- One may assume they look similar, but the Banjo body is made up of plastic and metal strings, whereas the Violin has a wooden body and usually silk or synthetic strings.
- The Banjo design has one or two prongs on its head where you can anchor some of those metal strings while playing, whereas there is no such thing as a “head” for the Violin.
- A Banjo has a plastic body made to be hit using two sticks, while a Violin has an empty wooden soundbox that amplifies vibrating strings into sound. These differences create differences in tone quality.
- For instance, the hollow voice of a violin makes it able to fill up larger spaces better than other stringed instruments like the Banjo. The banjo sound is more suited for smaller rooms or outdoors because of its loud volume.
- The Banjo is a staple of the bluegrass bands’ music as it produces a brighter tone, while the Violin is a staple of classical music, thus different styles of music.
- By extension, this means that each instrument has different repertoires, meaning there are certain pieces you cannot play on one instrument but can on the other because they were originally written for it.
Difference in Pitch
- There are many differences between the Banjo and Violin. The first is pitch; one has a higher pitch while the other has an even lower pitch.
- The note produced by 4-String Banjos generally lies above middle C on standard tuning, whereas notes of five-stringed violins lie below middle C on G (one octave below middle C). A 5-string violin typically tunes to G2 D3 A3 E4 like this: GDAD.
- Banjos and violins have been heavily influenced by their respective histories and purposes.
- In other words, how people used them has drastically changed throughout time. For example, the Banjo was initially used for song accompaniment, either vocally or instrumentally. It was adopted by banjo players for singing work songs and hollers because of its loud volume and portability.
Banjo vs Violin: Similarities
- Both Banjo and Violin play melodies that are typically higher than accompaniment played by other musicians.
- Both Banjo and Violin are stringed instruments, which means they play tunes with strings of different lengths.
- Both Banjo and Violin have similar modern genres, bluegrass music for the Banjo and classical music for the Violin.
Which Instrument is Easy to Play?
Because of their different playing styles and historical uses, it is more challenging to play Banjo than Violin. For example, Banjo requires you to use two sticks (also called plectrum), while a Violin only requires the use of one hand.
For another example, due to its history as song accompaniment, the Banjo typically has an accompanying beat that helps musicians practice timing and rhythm in addition to melody and harmony. This means there is often a steady 4/4 count underneath the melody that dictates when you should play each string. However, it can be difficult for beginning players because they may not be familiar with this kind of rhythm or trained in reading musical notation.
On the other hand, it’s easier to distinguish the sound of the Violin scale because it naturally fills up larger spaces with its loud volume.
Finally, at first glance, Banjo is easier to play than Violin because there are only four strings on a four-string Banjo while there’s double that number on a Violin. However, this difference is made up for by the fact that you can change what kind of Banjo you use; they come in five different sizes, which range from 4 string to 10 string (the tenth one being called plectrum).
Which Instrument is Harder to Learn?
Both instruments are instruments in their own right. They also have genres that distinguish them from each other (bluegrass for Banjo and classical music for Violin). Because of these different styles of song accompaniment, one might say it is more difficult to learn how to play bluegrass on Banjo or classical music on Violin because that would require knowledge of playing two different kinds of songs before being able to play both in their respective styles. Better learning requires proper practice time.
Which Instrument Is Right for You?
The right instrument decision depends upon the different styles of music you want to play. If you want to play fast, choose Banjo. If you’re interested in sustained notes and clear intonation (sounding the correct note at the same volume over time), then go with Violin.
Check out our blog on Banjo vs Guitar.
Ultimately, they each have something special about them, and neither of them is more difficult or easier than the other, it all depends on your personal preferences! So if you’re interested in playing music with accompaniment, then the Banjo might be for you. And if you’re interested in playing classical music, the Violin is a good choice.
You can also learn Banjo vs Guitar.